Friday, 13 April 2012

Indians, Indonesians cross cultures

Indians, Indonesians cross cultures (Saturday, January 30, 2010)
http://www.thejakartapost.com/news/2010/01/30/letters-indians-indonesians-cross-cultures.html
I refer to your editorial on Jan 26, wherein you (rightly) congratulated the Indian people for India's achievements. Truly, the credit for keeping our country a genuine democracy goes entirely to its people.
However, our post-Independence leadership was mature. They laid the foundations of our democracy. Our representatives en¬acted bills that gave the land to the tillers, the rented houses to tenants. This created a big middle class that is the backbone of our country.
Quite often, we Indians say that when we look at the quality of our leadership vis-a-vis the type of progress we have made, the most ardent of the atheists amongst us start believing that God does exist and He is taking care of India!
Your observations as regards the influence of India's culture on and beyond the Indian subcontinent are absolutely correct. Indian culture, Indian music and Indian food are popular every¬where in the world. Indonesian culture, including the Indonesian language, is also close to Indian culture and Sanskrit. Some 500 years ago, many Indonesian kingdoms were Hindu and most of the Indian epics find a place in Indonesian folklore. As we Indi¬ans go global, we proudly take these three features of our heritage along with us wherever we go.
Bung Karno and Pandit Nehru were very close and founded the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM). Biju Patnaik is still a household name in Indonesia. Indians are straight forward and don't indulge in double talk. Indians are grateful for the help other countries gave and never bites the hand that feeds. Even today, people of my generation are grateful for US aid.
Without American wheat under the PL-480, most Indians in 50’s and 60’s would have starved. Later, the "green revolution" swept India, so our younger generation doesn't even know the pangs of hunger. If Indians pledge their friendship, they stand by the pledge, they don't double cross.
Our Armed Forces remain in their barracks and don't overthrow elected governments. They do take stern measures in states which are being provoked by external elements to challenge its sovereignty, but our Armed Forces never raped the whole country like others often did! However, one of our failures has been the uncon¬trolled population explosion.
Not only Indonesia, but the whole of the Indian subcontinent should take note of our education system. Its quality is excellent and it's relatively inexpensive. Recently, I came across a book Nuclear Deception. It should be read by everybody belonging to Indian subcontinent; Indians, Pakistanis, Sri Lankans, etc. Indonesians should read it too because it is good “homework” for all!
K. B. KALE, JAKARTA

India, Pakistan have to bury hatchet

India, Pakistan have to bury hatchet
| Fri, 05/27/2011 8:00 AM

Farooq’s thought-provoking letter (May 13) suggested that Pakistan was looking for another option! Pakistan does need to reflect inwards for new options with an open mind by tracing its steps backwards to figure out what brought it to its present condition and then try to “undo” these steps.
I don’t know what Pakistanis feel, but we Indians feel we are basically from the same stock. We appear, think, dress and (barring beef) eat alike! Some Pakistanis are surely as resourceful and talented as we Indians are. I am sure that when Pakistan decides to stand on its own feet, they will also come up winners just like we Indians have! For its economic development and for building its basic infrastructure, Pakistan could take loans, but it should refuse to take “free” aid as such, since aid always has strings attached.
I can cite an example of India. In 1991, the Indian economy hit rock bottom and it didn’t have the foreign exchange it needed for its day-to-day requirements. In those dark days, India had to pledge (and actually shift) its bullion to the IMF to get foreign exchange. India took this humiliating step but still refused all “free” aid.
Such decisions have made Indians tough and tenacious! I hope Pakistan emulates this example on its way to greatness! The day would be written in letters of gold when Pakistanis realize that India is their genuine (and best) friend. Nawaz Sharif expressed these feelings the other day in Karachi when he urged them to stop looking at India as their biggest enemy. I really admire his courage and statesmanship to say this, because it ushers in a new golden era of Indo-Pakistan friendship. I sincerely hope that Pakistan extends its hand of friendship toward India. Borrowing a line from President Obama’s inaugural address I say India will extend a friendly hand toward Pakistan if it is willing to unclench its fist.
India has no interest in occupying any Pakistani territory that genuinely belongs to Pakistan. Though Partition was painful, Indians have gotten over it. If there had been no partition, Pakistanis, as a part of undivided India, would have been under uninterrupted democratic rule with all the freedoms Indians enjoy!
Their country would have enjoyed a high growth rate, respect in the World community and financial comforts that Indians enjoy: the widening gap between the “haves” and “have-nots” notwithstanding! Though we are split by partition, we can and must live as friendly neighbors. I feel it’s time to bury the old hatchet and start a new friendship with India!
K. B. Kale, Jakarta
Related News >>

Land mine kills 10 Indian police; Maoists blamed
india: Nuke-capable missile test-fired accurately
18 killed in India as truck plows into pilgrims
india: Anti-graft fast by ‘Gandhian’ activist pressures government

Follow our twitter @jakpost
& our public blog @blogIMO
Mail to a friend | Printer Friendly Version | Digg it! | Add to Del.icio.us! | submit to reddit | Stumble it! | Share on facebook | Share on tweeter |
Post Comments | Comments (12)

muradali_shaikh, U.K. | Tue, 31/05/2011 - 19:05pm

Western Powers closing the Cordon Around Pakistan: Syed Munawar Hasan Warns

LAHORE, May 26: The Jamaat e Islami chief, Syed Munawar Hasan, has said the US President Obama and British Premier Cameron’s resolve to wipe out terrorism from this region and check nuclear proliferation was an open challenge for Pakistan.
The colonial powers were closing their cordon against this country while the rulers and military leadership were the US allies in its war against this country, he deplored, in his address at a special workshop for provincial and district heads of the JI held at Mansoora on Thursday.
Syed Munawar Hasan expressed grave concern over the Abbotabad and Naval base attacks and said that if the nation did not free itself from the clutches of the US slaves, it would lose its independence and sovereignty. He said these two incidents showed worst security failure which had not only created a sense of insecurity among the people but also shaken their faith in these institutions.
He said, the resolutions adopted by the joint sessions of the parliament were not given any weight and there was no indication that the rulers would give up their policy to sell out national interests on US dictates. However, he declared that the JI would foil all anti-Pakistan designs of the slavish rulers with the public support.
Syed Munawar Hasan said that the current wave of terrorism in the country was part of the agenda of US, India and Israel against this country. He said the intelligence agencies were showing complete indifference about the security of national assets and sensitive installations, the situation was alarming but the national security institutions were shifting the responsibility to one another.
He said in Karachi, those busy in the politics of dead bodies and bloodshed had joined hands once again after rapprochement and the port city should get ready for more bloodshed and extortion. He however remarked that in this bloody game, neither the heirs of those killed in target killings had been compensated nor justice had been done to their families.
He was sure that if there was free and fair elections in Karachi, the JI would sweep. He clarified that the doors of the JI were open to all.
flag

Jamal K., South Africa | Tue, 31/05/2011 - 12:05pm

To
@mukesh raj dass, Auckland | Tue, 31/05/2011 - 04:05am

You write: "India-Pak Partition was a bad idea...and Gandhi saw it...".
.
My Opinion: Yes the Partition was a bad idea, but it is reversible, why not? Unfortunately most Hindus show strong pathological form of animosity to Pakistan, which is not conducive to a good union. Moreover, we in Pakistan, believe, that Hindus would take revenge for "our Imperial" Islamic past. But in those days not all Pakistanis were Muslims. They were also Hindus. My Great-Father, for axample, was a Hindu. Parts of our family are still Hindus and some are converted Muslims. We have still many Hindus rituals. See more details in:
.
Collins and Lapiere: Freedom at Midnight, 1975. (Translated from French into German and English). The book show the black and white photos of Gandhi and the 4 Hindu perpetrators who killed him. Hardly to believe, but true: Gandhi Jee war pro-Pakistan.
flag

mukesh raj dass, Auckland | Tue, 31/05/2011 - 04:05am

Let me emphasize as a Punjabi Hindu married to an Indonesian Muslim...i DO NOT dislike Pakistanis because they look like me, talk like me and are probably identical to me in terms of aspiration and family values....I only feel bad for them because they are Pawn in this notorious chess game for which the Pakistani military and China has alot to account for....In my opinion, rightly or wrongly, India-Pak Partition was a bad idea...and Gandhi saw it...

flag

mukesh raj dass, Auckland | Tue, 31/05/2011 - 04:05am

Every problem has a motive. Who will gain from the continuing conflict between India and Pakistan
(1) the Pakistani military (and ISI)(justify control of the country and massive budget playing on the Indian bogeyman).
(2)The powerful landlords in Pakistan
(3)China - Keeping its rival (India) economically down and getting the Pakistanis to do their dirty war by proxy via the military or terrorist organisations.
The losers are obviously the people of Pakistan and India as a whole. If Pakistan feels they have alot in common with China then they should change the name to Porkistan instead of Pakistan. Maybe they should ask the Tibetans, Uigur Muslims and Inner Mongolians how they treat other people better than India....they might learn something OR they prefer to ignore it just to get satisfy their obsession with India (as Obama reference to Pakistan's obsession). If Pakistan is deeply sensitive about Kashmir then why give a large chunk of Kashmir to China and yet fight with India to get the other chunk ???? Stupidity has no limit.
flag

Haafez, France | Tue, 31/05/2011 - 02:05am

Dear K. B. Kale from Jakarta
.
Thank you very much for your woderful article.
flag

NATO is a terrorist organisation. , A reader | Tue, 31/05/2011 - 02:05am

Nato choppers again violate Pakistani airspace in North Waziristan
.
Source: www.nation.com.pk (30.05.2011)
The NATO continues to violate Pakistani airspace as two helicopters again intruded into the Pakistani territory on Monday.
Sources said that two NATO choppers entered the Pakistani airspace to hunt militants in border area of North Waziristan Agency (NWA).
.
The NATO helicopters entered the border area, claiming that five members of Haqqani network have been arrested after the search operation.
It is worth mentioning here that two NATO helicopters had violated Pakistan’s airspace at Admi Kot post in North Waziristan Agency last week and had fired at the army check post, injuring two security personnel.
.
Meanwhile, tribesmen and citizens have expressed their anguish over repeated violation of NATO at border areas. Criticizing the suspicious silence of country’s leadership over NATO violations, they said that sovereignty of the country has been ruined in the hands of politicians who have nothing to do except safeguarding personal interests and increasing bank balances and properties.
They urged the armed forces to appropriately retaliate the violation by NATO forces so as to assure the countrymen that they were in safe hands.
flag

NATO is a terrorist organisation. , A reader | Tue, 31/05/2011 - 02:05am

Nato choppers again violate Pakistani airspace in North Waziristan
.
Source: www.nation.com.pk (30.05.2011)
The NATO continues to violate Pakistani airspace as two helicopters again intruded into the Pakistani territory on Monday.
Sources said that two NATO choppers entered the Pakistani airspace to hunt militants in border area of North Waziristan Agency (NWA).
.
The NATO helicopters entered the border area, claiming that five members of Haqqani network have been arrested after the search operation.
It is worth mentioning here that two NATO helicopters had violated Pakistan’s airspace at Admi Kot post in North Waziristan Agency last week and had fired at the army check post, injuring two security personnel.
.
Meanwhile, tribesmen and citizens have expressed their anguish over repeated violation of NATO at border areas. Criticizing the suspicious silence of country’s leadership over NATO violations, they said that sovereignty of the country has been ruined in the hands of politicians who have nothing to do except safeguarding personal interests and increasing bank balances and properties.
They urged the armed forces to appropriately retaliate the violation by NATO forces so as to assure the countrymen that they were in safe hands.

Hafiz Saeed is not just a ‘individual’ but a ‘mindset’

I refer to Faraz’s & Peter’s responses to my letter.
The last paragraph of my letter reflects my heartfelt sentiments that Indians & Pakistanis are “natural brothers” & must bury their hatchet & proceed on the path of prosperity. That is why I appreciated speech of Nawaz Sharif appealing his countrymen not to consider India as their enemy. The present Pakistani leadership wishes to improve Indo-Pak relations but its Army, which poses as Pakistan’s defender, would never allow it as their very existence depends on Pakistan’s enmity with India.
Zardari & Nawaz Sharif are real statesmen, but the ‘Rommels & Guderians’ of Pak Army (as my favourite Pakistani journalist Kamran Shafi calls them) would never allow them to forge friendship between us. Zardari, who has suffered most at the hands of Military (prolonged imprisonment) & home-grown terrorism (Benazir’s assassination) is a good person. After Mumbai Massacre of 2008, he ordered ISI chief to visit India to investigate & punish the culprits of this mayhem, but he forgot that Pak Armed Forces don’t obey his orders! Even in the infamous Memogate scandal, ISI chief preposterously flew to London to determine whether his constitutional boss Zardari was guilty of the infamous memo! Jai Ho!
While Pakistan’s COAS decides whether its civilian government stays in power, the situation in India is quite the opposite.
The CIA did plant the sapling of militancy in Pakistan’s Army to defeat Soviets, But Zia, then an outcast after hanging ZAB, grabbed the opportunity to improve his personal stature. He is the one who brought religion into Pakistani politics & planted the ‘sapling of militancy’ to retain power which has grown into a tree that kills its own creator, the ISI, as I wrote in my old letter “Export Surplus”! Their attacks on ISI offices & Mehran Naval Base are two examples! Today, Zia is a hated person in Pakistan.
After the Afghan War ended, it was Musharraf who let loose these well-trained militants in Kashmir.
Hafiz Saeed is not just an ‘individual’ but a ‘mindset’ that must be lawfully destroyed before it destroys Pakistan! It is Pakistan who should collect evidence against him. But with Pak Army’s support, how can the Pakistani civil government even touch him?
Giving India MFN status is more in Pakistan’s interest than India’s like US giving MFN status to China benefitted China!
As regards Peter’s comments, I can proudly say that Kashmiris participate in all elections held there & percentage of voting is higher than in India’s other states. Boycott calls by separatists like Geelani are routinely dismissed by Kashmiris. What does it show?
If Pakistan’s ISI stopped meddling in Kashmir, there will be peace on both sides, but will their army ever allow its own degradation? I recommend Faraz & Peter to read articles by Kamran Shafi & Ayaz Amir and the book “Nuclear Deception”.
Indians never claim they run a perfect democracy, but we are proud of being a democracy & hope that Pakistanis also join us with equal pride. Our democracy is just 60 years old & we are still learning how to run it smoothly. It would be wrong to compare it with seasoned democracies of UK, USA, etc.
I hope Peter knows that our constitution gives our Judiciary total independence, a matter of pride for us. Though we laud the courage of Pakistan’s Chief Justice Chaudhry, we feel that memogate & Gilani cases in Pakistani Supreme Court are just charades.
Zardari’s 50-million-rupee ‘nazrana’ (gift) to Ajmer dargah would have benefitted the flood-affected people of Sindh much more!
K B Kale, Camp: USA

Wednesday, 11 April 2012

Why Pakistan blames everything on US policies?

Pakistani President Zardari has just finished his private visit to India to pay his respects at the dargah of Hazrat Khwaja Moinuddin Chishti in Ajmer, but Medias on both sides of the border are trying to get the most out of this visit to raise their viewers’ ratings.

I just saw the interview of one of a well-known Pakistani journalist, Hamid Mir, on one of the news channels in India covering this visit. When its anchorwoman asked him whether it was not true that Pak Army & ISI clandestinely support Hafiz Muhammad Saeed as an anti-Indian asset, instead of answering in a 'YES' or a 'NO', he used a standard ruse of blaming all on USA which most Pakistani politicians & journalists use! "It was CIA that had started helping terrorists (aka mujahedeen) during Russian occupation of Afghanistan.” He said!

I was flabbergasted! Why should such an eminent journalist use CIA as his shield? Reagan might have goaded Zia, but why did Zia allowed it? And if Zia got goaded (as did Musharraf some thirty years later), why blame the USA? Why should Pakistan downgrade itself into a mercenary state to fight others' wars for money with no prick of conscience? Actually this eminent journalist should have used this opportunity to explain this to Pakistani people.

It is time Pakistan refuses American aid & stands on its own feet and behaves like a true sovereign nation. I sincerely hope the Pakistani political leadership realizes this, orders its Army to the barracks, limits the actions of its fanatic religious elements only to the religious matters within their masjids & seminaries and shows the courage to stand up to Military bullies to rule their country democratically to serve Pakistan's interests leading to prosperity & betterment of its people.

Most of Indians await this development with fervent hope & I am sure India will help Pakistan to India's limits as we two are “natural friends”!

I also wish President Zardari had donated his 5 crore rupees for the betterment of his flood-affected people of Sindh who got hit by record floods for two consecutive years and are crying for help.

K B Kale, Jakarta